Skip to main content

The Finkler Question by Howard Jacobson

I cannot tell whether I hated this book, could just barely bear it, or what.

I was consumed by the idea that it had won the Booker Prize, and really there was something about the studied conversational language that carried me forward through to the end. There were painful, truthful elements about pain, infidelity and lifetime friendships that rang true across the plaza like a church bell. Still, I think maybe it was abysmal.


But I am a Jewish professional, as a Deputy Director of the Contemporary Jewish Museum, and so I felt some sense of obligation to get to the end and more fully grasp over what the author was puzzling.


A few quotes made me want to fold down the page and refer to them later:

  • [Parenthetically the author writes,] “(he would have said his faith but Finkler was Finkler and Finkler had no faith)”
    p. 56

  • ‘So this museum…’ Finkler said, when the table was cleared. Hephzibah inclined her head on his direction. ‘…don’t we have enough of them already?’ ‘Museums in general you mean?’ ‘Jewish museums. Everywhere you go now, every town, every shtetl, you find a Holocaust museum. Do we need a Holocaust museum in Stevenage or Letchworth’
    p. 179 (Funny to think that this book I had such trouble with, kinda really was about a Jewish museum…ugh.)

  • It was so lovely, bathing in the lucidities of a thinker's preliminary thoughts…With Maimonides he was downing by the end of the first sentence.

    ‘Some have been of opinion,’ Maimonides began, ‘that by the Hebrew zelem, the shape and the figure of a thing is to be understood, and this explanation led men to believe in the corporeality [of the Divine Being]: for they thought that the words “Let us make man in our zelem” (Gen i.26), implied that God had the form of a human being, i.e., that He had figure and shape, and that consequently, He was corporeal.’ Of themselves, Treslove believed he might have made some headway, with these refined distinctions relating to the appearance, or not, of the divine…at that point he was among the mystics and the dreamers. …This religion is too old for me, Treslove thought. He felt like a child lost in a dark forest of decrepit lucubrations.
    p. 196 (Does this speak in an interesting way to the distinction of Jewish learning, and the sometimes growing up Jewish feeling?...oh, essentialism: it is a dangerous road…)

  • He stayed up late watching television, trying t stay away from his computer. Enough with his poker. But poker served a purpose. T.S. Eliot told Auden that the reason he played patience night after night was that it was the nearest thing to being dead. Patience, poker…What difference?
    p. 275

    (Oh, how I love T.S. Eliot...and Auden.)
  • Comments

    Popular posts from this blog

    BREAKING NEWS: USC to Absorb HUC in LA?

    This just in from "The God Blog." A source told Jewish Journal editor-in-chief Rob Eshman that the University of Southern California and Hebrew Union College-Jewish institute of Religion, which already share some faculty and facilities, are working on a deal to fold the L.A. campus into USC as a Jewish studies program. “Its a win win,“ the source said. “HUC gets a big chunk of money for what it owns—about a block of prime real estate by the USC campus—and USC gets to solidify a Jewish studies and outreach program that it has been building for some time now.“ Hebrew Union College in Los Angeles has been having big problems -- a consolidation of resources may present a novel and impactful solution. VERY INTERESTING.

    Why Go to A Conference Anyways?

    @lidja @lyndakelly61 @futureofmuseums @creativemerc @museum_flavor pLz look http://tinyurl.com/qxlja4 &here http://bit.ly/q1mhV assoc./conf. grpthink @RichardMcCoy @DanielCull very import.

    A Year-end Letter Update from James and Family

    Dear Friends and Family, On the brink of the new year on December 31, 2019 we stood at the foot of Kehinde Wiley's brand new monumental equestrian sculpture in downtown Richmond at the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts. There were a bunch of families gathered around taking pictures together. Emblematic of this entire year and entitled “ Rumors of War ,” the monument depicts an unarmed Black man in heroic pose atop a horse. The man’s sneakers are in the stirrups, looking back over their shoulder like Napoleon as they ride forward up a ridge . It was a strange harbinger of the year that was, and how it’s going. Kamala Harris will be named our vice president in a few weeks. In between, the apocalyptic has been commonplace; I mean, what a year. Emil started high school this fall. Graduation this past spring from Mark Day School was likely the year’s highlight. Karen is still at Mark Day. This fall they've been doing hybrid learning. It’s the first time Karen and Emil have not been goi